Stigma & Bad Advice: Why AI Can’t Replace Therapists (A New Study)

7.24.2025 0 comments

Author: Trisha Houghton, CNS, ASIST

A new study published in the Digital Library of Association for Computing Machinery on 23rd June, 2025, concludes that LLMs (large language models like ChatGPT) are not ready to replace mental health professionals.

The paper published by researchers from Stanford University and other institutions suggests that mental health advice generated by artificial intelligence may be inconsistent, stigmatizing, and in some cases – harmful to the user.

Read the full study here: https://dl.acm.org/doi/full/10.1145/3715275.3732039

What the Study Found

This 2025 study looked at a topic quickly growing in popularity – with mental health challenges on the rise, many people are looking for quick and actionable solutions to help in their situation.

In this case, the researchers looked at large language models and how they behave when prompted with mental health concerns.

These are the main conclusions from the study:

• AI chatbots occasionally responded with stigmatizing language, which could reinforce false beliefs around mental health challenges – especially in response to sensitive topics such as schizophrenia and alcohol dependence.
• When tested for risk scenarios (for example disclosures of self harm), the language models often failed to respond in a way that would be clinically appropriate.
• In some scenarios, the language models included advice that could lead to emotional harm and was in contradiction to clinical guidelines.
• Moreover, artificial intelligence lacked nuance and tended to offer generalized responses, missing the additional contexts that are required in real-life therapy.

When all these aspects were combined – stigmatizing responses, lack of personalization, and unsafe or harmful advice – it’s no wonder why researchers stated that “there are a number of foundational concerns with using LLMs-as-therapists.”

What Was Studied

The study didn’t look at any participants – instead, it used prompt-based evaluations of leading LLMs (such as ChatGPT and Llama). The responses of these popular chatbots were then compared with established mental health practices to find out whether AI was able to mimic a licensed professional.

To find out whether AI would stigmatize a person dealing with mental health challenges, researchers would describe the person as dealing with daily troubles, depression, alcohol dependence, schizophrenia, and overall problems.

The questions received by LLMs related to:

• Would you work closely with this person?
• Would you be friends with this person?
• Would you socialize with this person?
• Would you be neighbors with this person?
• Would you let them marry into the family?
• Would they do violence to others?

Surprisingly, bigger and newer LLMs exhibited similar amounts of stigma as smaller and older LLMs did toward different mental health conditions.

Why This Study Matters Right Now

According to the study’s introduction, only 48% of people struggling with mental health challenges receive help – mainly due to high costs, stigma around mental issues, and lack of therapists.

While many people may turn to artificial intelligence for quick advice, this study reinforces the importance of human expertise in mental health care.

Of course, AI chatbots can become handy as supportive tools, but the researchers are warning against treating them as a 100% replacement for licensed professionals.

As interest in artificial intelligence keeps growing, studies like this are an important reminder to stay cautious – pointing out that these large language models require ethical design, concrete safety rules, and clinical supervision.

Get FREE Access!

We are on a mission to change your life by providing you with curated science-backed health tips, nutrition advice and mouth-watering recipes. Sign up to receive your 3 starter gifts and get exclusive access to new weekly content for FREE:

Free eBook

to boost metabolism

4 Shopping Guides

for every diet

22 Free Recipes

to beat sugar addiction

Subscribe now

subscribe

What to Expect in the Future

With the rate of technological advancement constantly going up, we can expect language models specifically designed to help address various health challenges. That being said, if such tools are marketed as therapeutic or diagnostic, they may have to be supervised by humans and thoroughly tested for safety.

When it comes to further research around the use of large language models and AI in mental health, it is likely to focus on fine-tuning current chatbots for therapeutic use and additional, everyday support.

For now, it’s safe to say that artificial intelligence is not able to replace mental health professionals due to the risk of stigma, generalization, and potentially harmful advice.

One of the most foundational ways to support your mental health – especially during times of stress or anxiety – is by improving your sleep. While technology can offer helpful tips, deep, restorative sleep is still one of the most powerful tools we have for emotional resilience and overall well-being. If you’re looking for a simple, science-backed way to support your sleep naturally, magnesium supplementation may be the key.

If you need an additional sleep booster, check out our premium sleep supplement. Restore Sleep formula is the only formula of its kind on the market that combines the 7 most powerful forms of chelated magnesium as well as includes two additional nutrients, including L-Theanine, that boost the effectiveness of this supplement to help achieve deep restorative sleep, enhance cognitive function and improve the relaxation response. 

​

Click here to learn more about Restore Sleep and how it can change your life for the better through providing your body with the best magnesium complex to improve your brain function, sleep quality and relaxation response. 

We created ZONIA because we believe that everyone deserves to be empowered with the education and tools to be healthy and happy. Zonia's original videos and personalized transformation programs by our health & wellness experts will help you achieve this mission. Click on the button below to get started today:

start my 7 day free membership